Who Watches the Rewatchers · Oct 30, 2026 · 47:03
Listen in the Podli app 🎧
Follow your favourite podcasts, listen offline and in the car with CarPlay and Android Auto, and always pick up where you left off. Free to try.
Jarrod and Alan finally get to a top-tier one, and they frame "The Wish" as Buffy's It's a Wonderful Life — the episode that answers what Sunnydale becomes if Buffy never came to town. Gutted by the Xander betrayal and freshly back from her injury, Cordelia befriends a too-eager new girl named Anya, complains that Buffy is the common thread in all her misery, and wishes her away — not knowing Anya is Anyanka, a vengeance demon for scorned women, and that the amulet around her neck will make it so. What follows is a bleather-clad nightmare: a vampire-run Sunnydale under curfew, the Bronze converted into a feeding hive, Willow and Xander as the Master's prized, sadistic underlings (Vamp Willow toying with a caged, powerless "puppy" Angel), and a grim, militarized Buffy who arrives all business — proof, as the guys put it, that without her friends she'd have turned out much more like Faith. Alan traces the episode's real lineage to the X-Men's "Days of Future Past" (Whedon's beloved Kitty Pryde thrust into a ruined future) and Star Trek's Mirror universe, while the two wrestle with what the talisman is really for, whether it's just a narrative device, and a genuinely rich tangent on relics, sacramental imagination, and whether objects and places can be imbued with grace — Battle of Peachtree Creek and all. There's the free-will-versus-circumstance question (would the world really have gone this bad?), the gruesome blood-decanting assembly line, and a final battle where the good guys fall one by one until Giles gambles everything on smashing the amulet. It ends the instant it began — Anya, fresh-faced and powerless, staring at a Cordelia whose wish simply won't take. Plus a look ahead: Amends, the First Evil, and the bigger mythology to come.
Note: these are recorded WAY in advance, and there is some banter about looking forward to the Buffy Reboot that we now know is not going to happen.
#WhoWatchesTheRewatchers #BuffyRewatch #TheWish #BuffyS3E9 #BtVSSeason3 #BuffyPodcast #Anyanka #Anya #VampWillow #TheMaster #Cordelia #AlternateTimeline #DaysOfFuturePast #KittyPryde #MirrorUniverse #ItsAWonderfulLife #RipperGiles #FreeWill #SunnydaleHigh #JossWhedon #ScoobyGang #BuffyAndAngel #VengeanceDemon
Episodes: Who Watches the Rewatchers