#116: [Inside the Mind] Andrew Reynolds: Reducing Cognitive Fatigue, Skill Development Lag, and How to Play Freely

Pressure, perfectionism, and overthinking—three traits that quietly sabotage golfers chasing freedom on the course.

In this conversation, Andrew Reynolds, cognitive performance coach and founder of The COG Coach, breaks down what it truly means to play with freedom—and why most golfers never achieve it. He shares how to design practice that mirrors real pressure, add consequence to every rep, and build process-driven routines that hold up when the stakes rise.

We explore the hidden cost of mental fatigue, how to protect cognitive energy over 18 holes, and the psychological "skill-development lag" that frustrates so many golfers chasing progress. Andrew also explains the three-step framework to reframe destructive self-talk, find safety in discomfort, and make your best golf automatic under pressure—whether you're grinding for your first club championship or a tour card.

In this episode, you'll learn:

• What "playing with freedom" actually means—and how to create it on demand
• How to add consequence to practice so it transfers under pressure
• The accountability hacks that keep you in the hard reps (where skill grows)
• A simple blueprint for durable pre-shot and pre-round routines
• How to spot and reframe irrational self-talk in real time
• Managing cognitive energy and decision fatigue across 18 holes
• Why process beats results—and how to believe it when scores matter
  
  

Get your pencils ready and start listening. 

P.S. Curious to learn more about the results my clients are experiencing and what they say about working with me? Read more here.

More About Andrew Reynolds

Andrew Reynolds is a Cognitive Performance Coach based in the UK. Andrew helps golfers, from weekend amateurs to touring professionals, develop the ability to perform under pressure and play their best golf when it matters.

You can reach Andrew via email at andy@thecogcoach.com or at his website www.thecogcoach.com. 

Play to Your Potential On (and Off) the Course

1. Schedule a Mindset Coaching Discovery Call
2. Subscribe to the More Pars than Bogeys Newsletter
3. Download my "Play Your Best Round" free hypnosis audio recording.

High-Performance Hypnotherapy and Mindset Coaching

Paul Salter - known as The Golf Hypnotherapist - is a High-Performance Hypnotherapist and Mindset Coach who leverages hypnosis and powerful subconscious reprogramming techniques to help golfers of all ages and skill levels overcome the mental hazards of their minds so they can shoot lower scores and play to their potential.

He has over 16 years of coaching experience working with high performers in various industries, helping them get unstuck, out of their own way, and unlock their full potential.

Click here to learn more about how high-performance hypnotherapy and mindset coaching can help you get out of your own way and play to your potential on (and off) the course. 

Instagram: @thegolfhypnotherapist 

Twitter: @parsoverbogeys

Key Takeaways:

• Practice like you play: Bring course elements (targets, variability, consequence) to the range so pressure isn't a surprise.
• Add consequence: Games with "must-complete" tasks (e.g., 3 fairways in a row) simulate tournament feels.
• Quality beats quantity: Short, intense, focused sessions > marathon ball-beating.
• Protect cognitive energy: Strong routines reduce decision fatigue and steady your state under stress.
• Reframe the story: Emotions come from interpretation; catch absolutes ("always/never") and replace them with rational truth.
• Calibrate emotion: Even "negative" emotions can be adaptive when properly dialed.
• Detach from score: Commit to the shot in front of you; outcome improves as a byproduct.

Key Quotes:

• "Make practice look like the golf course, not the course look like practice."
• "Consequence is the fastest way to simulate pressure."
• "The hard, uncomfortable reps are where skill is actually built."
• "Pick a target, visualize, commit—that's the billboard I'd put on every tee."
• "It's not the first tee that makes you anxious; it's the story you tell yourself about it."
• "Process is part of outcome—not something separate from it."
• "There's a skill-development lag: keep going through it instead of restarting with a new method."

Time Stamps:

• 00:00 Playing with Freedom: The Key to Golf Success
• 02:47 Gamification in Practice: Adding Consequences to Training
• 05:37 Embracing Discomfort: The Path to Skill Development
• 08:49 Quality Over Quantity: Setting Expectations for Practice
• 11:38 Cognitive Energy: Managing Mental Fatigue in Golf
• 14:18 Self-Talk and Emotional Awareness: The Mental Game of Golf
• 22:10 Understanding Self-Talk in Golf
• 23:33 The Art of Reframing Thoughts
• 24:52 Emotional Calibration for Performance
• 27:45 Managing Confidence and Expectations
• 29:06 Focusing on the Process