RIGGED: BYU Football's College Football Playoff Hopes in JEOPARDY as CFP Committee Changes Landscape | Everydayer Club Mailbag

The College Football Playoff Committee’s new strength-of-conference schedule metric might derail the BYU football program’s postseason dreams. Are Kalani Sitake and his BYU Cougars fighting a losing battle as the CFP continues to shift its criteria, apparently favoring the SEC? Jake Hatch spotlights the power plays driving playoff selections and questions if BYU fans should brace for more heartbreak, or if a Big 12 Conference title run is the only answer to counter conference bias.

The episode opens with Jake Hatch breaking down ESPN’s reports on the CFP Committee’s adoption of a new conference opponent evaluation tool. This metric, born in response to SEC lobbying, allows the committee to compare a team’s conference strength-of-schedule in finer detail—potentially pushing Big 12 teams like BYU behind their SEC and Big Ten peers even with similar or better records. Jake Hatch argues this move isn’t just about fairness; it’s a response to SEC frustration over recent Big Ten national titles and their belief in the SEC being the best league. He calls out the committee’s history of shifting standards—like last season, when BYU’s Big 12 title game loss led to a drop in the rankings, while Alabama remained unaffected by a similar loss in the SEC Championship Game.

With the playoff field crowded and the possibility of the Big 12 becoming remaining a one-bid league, Jake Hatch places the onus firmly on BYU: win the Big 12 championship and remove all doubt. The episode explores why Notre Dame’s independence keeps them immune from this metric, spotlighting a system that effectively safeguards bluebloods while raising hurdles for outsiders like BYU.

Listeners can expect a rapid-fire mailbag tackling questions about TCU game confidence—Jake Hatch feels good about BYU’s chances at Amon G. Carter Stadium—and the development of BYU’s defensive line behind Keanu Tanuvasa and Tausili Akana. Is the defensive line finally taking that long-awaited step forward, or will they be exposed against tougher Big 12 competition? Health updates on Bear Bachmeier reassure fans, and a viral story about the Bachmeier family is set straight.

Hot topics include whether BYU needs a program-defining win over Notre Dame or Utah to truly alter national perception, insight into style points versus substance, and why offensive tweaks—like getting the tight ends more involved—could be difference-makers as conference play heats up. Jake Hatch also addresses the PCSA’s potential impact on BYU, the athlete’s voice in looming legislation, and the double standard BYU faces in national media.

Can the Cougars shatter the ceiling and force the CFP Committee’s hand, or will shifting criteria forever keep BYU out of college football’s elite?

Support Locked On Cougars:

Follow & Subscribe on all Podcast platforms and on YouTube!

Join the NEW Locked On Cougars Everydayer Club by clicking here!

If you never miss an episode, it’s time to make it official. Join the Locked On Everydayer Club and get ad-free audio, access to our members-only Discord, and more — all built for our most loyal fans. 

Click here to learn more and join your team’s community: https://lockedonpodcasts.com/everydayerclub

Jake Hatch brings you daily coverage of the BYU Cougars with the Locked On Cougars Podcast. Locked On Cougars brings BYU fans the latest news and comprehensive coverage when it comes to the BYU football and basketball programs as well as a look at the other teams in the BYU athletic department. Jake gives you his unique insights and insider information about the Cougs as they continue "on the trail to fame and glory" every weekday, along with interviews with players, coaches, experts, and alumni that you will not find anywhere else.

Support Us By Supporting Our Sponsors!

KALSHI
For a limited time, Download Kalshi and use code Locked On to get $25 when you trade $25. Kalshi. Trade what’s next. 

SupplyHouse
Visit https://SupplyHouse.com/TM to learn more about becoming a Trade Master.  Use promo code  S H 5 College  for five percent off your first order.  
SupplyHouse. Real people. Real service. 

Odoo
Great organizations win because operations matter. And that’s why you should get Odoo. Try for free today at https://Odoo.com/lockedon.

Square
Get up to $200 off Square hardware when you sign up at https://square.com/go/COLLEGE ! #squarepod

LARINECO
Give Larine a try. Right now, Larine Co is offering our listeners up to 50% off at https://BUYLARINE.com/LOCKEDONCOLLEGE. 

5-Hour ENERGY
Bring on the sweetness with Cotton Candy 5-hour ENERGY®️ shots—available online now at https:/5hourENERGY.com or on Amazon. 

Gametime
Today's