Follow your favourite podcasts, listen offline and in the car with CarPlay and Android Auto, and always pick up where you left off. Free to try.
Was justice served when Jeannie Donald was convicted of murdering eight-year-old Helen Priestly in 1934 Aberdeen? This episode examines the "Aberdeen Sack Murder," a case that made Scottish legal history as one of the first convictions based entirely on forensic evidence. The prosecution had no eyewitnesses. Instead, they relied on hairs found in the hessian sack matching Jeannie's brush, fibres from the sack found in her home, and a rare bacterium from Helen's medical condition discovered throughout the Donald flat. The jury took just 18 minutes to convict. But the story doesn't end there: Jeannie's death sentence was commuted partly because the court believed she may have killed Helen only by accident, and she was released in 1944. The National Police Library notes the scientific proof "was not strong," and an editor later surmised the death may have been accidental and then covered up. Jeannie never confessed. Did the forensic evidence prove her guilt beyond doubt, or did it prove only that Helen had been in her home? Press play and decide for yourself. New episode every week—subscribe and leave your review. 🎧
