Follow your favourite podcasts, listen offline and in the car with CarPlay and Android Auto, and always pick up where you left off. Free to try.
The episode details the tragic disappearance and murder of Valerie Tindle, a 17-year-old from Arlington, Indiana, who was killed by her neighbor and employer, Patrick Scott. After a five-month search, investigators discovered the teenager’s remains hidden in a homemade wooden box buried on Scott’s property. During a recorded interrogation, Scott confessed to strangling the victim with a belt, claiming he acted to prevent her from allegedly blackmailing him. The narrative highlights the deceptive behavior of the perpetrator, who maintained a facade of a helpful neighbor while concealing his horrific crime. Ultimately, Scott accepted a plea deal resulting in a 57-year prison sentence, leaving a grieving family to seek justice and closure. The accounts serve as a sobering reminder of the potential dangers posed by trusted individuals within a community.
