The Fingerprints Are The Work (Maggie Fost, VP of Design at Shopify)

In this episode, we sit down with Maggie Fost, VP of Design at Shopify, to explore what it means to leave a genuine imprint on creative work—especially in an era increasingly dominated by automation and efficiency. We trace Maggie’s journey from indie music labels to the tech world's frontlines, discussing lessons learned about craftsmanship, authenticity, and the art of leading creative teams.

We kick off by reflecting on the story behind the ‘thumbiness’ in Wallace and Gromit animations—a metaphor for the deliberate choice to keep the human touch in even the most polished products. Maggie shares how these same principles inform her approach at Shopify, including her practice of building “grace notes” into digital products: those small, sometimes unnoticed moments that signal a real person cared enough to imbue the work with warmth, surprise, and delight.

We also tackle the nuanced relationship between humans and AI tools. Rather than rejecting technology, Maggie describes how her team uses it to remove drudgery and focus their energy on creative contributions that can’t be copied or mass-produced. She offers grounded strategies for leaders who want to foster a culture where soul-filled resonance is valued over sterile perfection.

Whether you’re a creative professional, team leader, or founder, you’ll find concrete ideas for defending the idiosyncrasies that make your work original—and ensuring your team’s fingerprints remain visible.

Five Key Learnings

1. Intentional Imperfection: Embracing and defending the small marks of humanity—what Nick Park called “thumbiness”—results in work with a distinct, unforgettable soul. The aim is not sloppiness but deliberate, rigorous inclusion of the human touch.
2. Grace Notes Matter: Tiny, unexpected elements—like the ‘bud vase’ in the Volkswagen Beetle—signal care and delight. These grace notes are rarely mandated in a brief, but their absence is deeply felt, leaving work technically correct but emotionally flat.
3. AI as a Tool, Not a Replacement: Efficiency-driven automation can erase the very things that make creative work meaningful. Leaders must be vigilant not to let tools dictate what the work should be—AI should remove toil, not soul.
4. Flexible Roles Increase Resilience: Allowing team members to step outside rigid role descriptions and pursue projects that spark their curiosity energizes teams, builds capacity, and fosters cross-functional strength able to withstand rapid change.
5. Be Hard on Work, Gentle on People: High standards for creative output should be matched by grace toward collaborators. In a remote, fast-moving context, investing in relationships directly impacts the quality of what’s produced.

Bring Todd Henry to speak to your team or event at ToddHenry.com/speaking

See Todd Henry's books at ToddHenry.com/books

Get full interviews and bonus content for free! Just join the list at DailyCreativePlus.com.

Mentioned in this episode:

New Keynote & Workshop: The Infinite Lever

Every leader I talk with is asking some version of the same question right now: What happens to my people as AI absorbs more of the work? That question is why I built a new keynote and workshop called The Infinite Lever. It's about the human capacities that get more valuable in an AI world, not less, and how to develop them on purpose before the window closes. If you're planning an event this year, visit toddhenry.com/speaking.