Eerie Edinburgh · Apr 12, 2026 · 25:49
Listen in the Podli app 🎧
Follow your favourite podcasts, listen offline and in the car with CarPlay and Android Auto, and always pick up where you left off. Free to try.
When people think of Scotland’s major battles, places like Bannockburn or Culloden usually come to mind.
But just outside the town of Crieff, there’s another battlefield that doesn’t get the same attention - Sheriffmuir.
In 1715, two armies met there during the Jacobite rising. By the end of the day, neither side had won. Both claimed victory, but the outcome settled nothing. The campaign stalled, and what followed wasn’t a clean retreat or a clear defeat - it was something far less defined.
And that aftermath didn’t stay on the battlefield.
In this episode, we look at what happened next - not just the history, but the accounts that have been reported in and around Crieff since.
From repeated sightings of a man standing at the roadside along the A85, to a strange figure seen on a path at the edge of town, and the long-standing reports tied to Ferntower House.
These aren’t well-known stories, and some are being shared here for the first time. Most come from people who experienced something, tried to make sense of it, and were left with more questions than answers.
I’d also like to thank Scott for passing on his family’s account, and for taking the time to share the details behind it. Stories like that don’t always make it beyond a small circle, so having it sent through made a real difference when putting this episode together.