Pat Garrett said he shot Billy the Kid in the dark at Fort Sumner, New Mexico, on July 14th, 1881, but one of his own deputies took one look at the body and told him he'd killed the wrong man. Sixty-seven years later, a lawyer asked an 88-year-old man in Hamilton, Texas, if he was Billy the Kid; the man laughed and showed him the door, then stepped outside, where his wife couldn't hear, and told him he was – and that he wanted a pardon before he died.
READ or DOWNLOAD the full transcript of this episode:
https://weirddarkness.tiny.us/4yvkdm4rIN THIS EPISODE: This episode of Weird Darkness runs from the disputed death of Billy the Kid to a Louisville poltergeist named Lucy, a car that rolled backward on the Cuba Road bridge, a knife stuck in a kitchen floor, the ghosts of Blackpool Pleasure Beach, an old man's spirit pounding on a bedroom wall, shadow people in an Illinois bar, a dream two strangers shared, a cavalier ghost in Hull, and the London nights that led Charles Dickens to A Christmas Carol.
CHAPTERS & TIME STAMPS (All Times Approximate)…
00:00:00.000 = Show Open
00:00:47.425 = Did Billy The Kid Actually Die in 1950?
00:11:38.462 = A Poltergeist Named Lucy ***
01:12:30.371 = Burning at Cuba Road Bridge ***
01:14:45.558 = Bible Study Haunting
01:16:04.091 = Blackpool Ghosts
01:18:41.678 = Dead Sleep
01:37:05.952 = The Haunting of Lilian at the 9th Street Pub
01:47:34.844 = In Dreams ***
01:51:51.515 = The Cavalier
01:56:33.984 = Ghosts of Christmas
02:01:03.319 = Show Close
*** = Begins immediately after inserted ad break
SOURCES and RESOURCES:
“Did Billy The Kid Actually Die in 1950?” by Troy Taylor: (link no longer available)
“Ghosts of Christmas” by Charlie Dexter: (link no longer available)
“In Dreams” from the book “Tales Too Strange To Be Fiction” by Cindy Parmiter:
https://amzn.to/45YWZXj“The Cavalier” from the book “My Haunted Life” by G. Michael Vasey:
https://amzn.to/45Vm4Cm“Blackpool Ghosts” by Alan Toner from “100 True Ghost Stories”:
https://amzn.to/3Ft80Y3“Dead Sleep” by Annie Wilder, from “House of Spirits and Whispers”:
https://amzn.to/4kvU5iI"The Haunting of Lilian At The 9th Street Pub” by Randy Beasley
“A Poltergeist Named Lucy” by David Domine from “True Ghost Stories and Eerie Legends from America's Most Haunted Neighborhood”
https://amzn.to/4cssuLQ“Burning At Cuba Road Bridge” by Randy Beasley
Special thanks to MoJo for “Bible Study Haunting”
(Over time links may become invalid, disappear, or have different content. I always make sure to give authors credit for the material I use whenever possible. If I somehow overlooked doing so for a story, or if a credit is incorrect, please let me know and I will rectify it in these show notes immediately. Some links included above may benefit me financially through qualifying purchases.)
WeirdDarkness® is a registered trademark. Copyright ©2026, Weird Darkness.
*No AI Voices Are Used In The Narration Of This Podcast*
EPISODE SYNOPSIS:
This episode of Weird Darkness opens at Fort Sumner, New Mexico, on July 14th, 1881, when Lincoln County Sheriff Pat Garrett shot a man in the dark at Pete Maxwell's house and said it was Billy the Kid, though deputy John Poe looked at the body and told him he'd killed the wrong man. In 1948, attorney William Morrison found William Henry "Brushy Bill" Roberts in Hamilton, Texas, an 88-year-old who said he was the Kid and wanted a pardon from New Mexico Governor Thomas Mabry before he died.
From there, author David Dominé tells of buying the Widmer House at 1228 South Third Street in Old Louisville, Kentucky, in 1999, after the previous owner mentioned a resident poltergeist named Lucy who didn't like things changed around. Pictures kept falling, footsteps came down the front stairs, coffee he never made scented the kitchen, and workmen sanding the floors uncovered a flat iron's burn mark in the old housekeeper's room.
Next, a paranormal team parked in neutral on the Cuba Road bridge past White Cemetery felt the car roll slowly backward and heard a whistle, just as one investigator's left hand and another's left ear began to burn as though someone held lighters to them.
After that, a youth leader came home from teaching a Halloween Bible study to find a flimsy kitchen knife standing point-down in the floor of a house that had been empty all day.
At Blackpool Pleasure Beach in England, staff have reported the clatter of clogs inside the ghost train, blamed on Cloggy, a ride operator who died about 20 years ago, along with a figure resembling Karl Marx in the Star pub and a girl of about nine in Sir Hiram Maxim's gift shop.
Then a single mother who had just moved into an old house with her children, Molly and Jack, woke at 1:11 a.m. to a woman's hollow voice and then a pounding in the wall behind her headboard, which she pinned on Leon, the old man who had lived there for 30 years.
In LaSalle, Illinois, a 2010 overnight investigation at the 9th Street Pub with bartenders Neil and Jeff turned up shadow people who blocked a flashlight on request, an unseen jab to one investigator's stomach, and pool balls rolling in what was once the living room of Lillian, whose house the bar took over after her death.
Later, a high school humanities teacher dreamed he was a wolf ch