Podlipodcast player Webplayer

JMU Sports News Network

JMU Sports News Network

JMU vs App State Recap: OT Loss, Two-Point Debate & Playoff Hopes | JMU Sports News Podcast

JMU Sports News Network · Oct 27, 2026 · 52:52

0:0052:52

Listen in the Podli app 🎧

Follow your favourite podcasts, listen offline and in the car with CarPlay and Android Auto, and always pick up where you left off. Free to try.

JMU’s undefeated season is over. The Dukes lost at App State in overtime after Billy Napier chose to kick the extra point instead of going for two to win in regulation.

Bennett and Jack break down everything that went wrong, starting with why they dismissed App State on paper, and why a roster of FCS and D2 transfers looked rattled in the biggest road environment of its life.

They go through the two-point decision and the overtime play call, the first-half drive chart (too many punts and too few points), and the pass rush numbers that worry them (142 pressures but very few sacks). They also argue about whether JC Evans should play more in the two-quarterback system and whether JMU deserved to be in the playoff conversation in the first place. Then they run through the Sun Belt East and title game picture, why they’re ready to leave the Sun Belt’s fan bases behind, and a full Overreaction Corner built from 136 submissions. Plus: JMU Sports News tailgate plans for the Coastal game.

️ TIMESTAMPS 0:00 – Intro: the “poop curse” and who the account really is 1:17 – How we’re handling the loss 1:36 – We didn’t see this coming: dismissing App State 3:16 – The biggest moment this roster has ever played in 3:59 – Camden Coleman’s rough night 5:06 – JMU’s worst game, and still a chance to win in regulation 5:31 – The two-point conversion debate 9:05 – The first play of overtime 11:29 – Drive-chart breakdown: the first half 13:04 – Complementary football disappears 16:00 – Did JMU belong in the playoff conversation? 18:18 – Pass rush problems: pressures vs. sacks 22:56 – Big-picture takes and the cope 24:28 – “If you’d told me 7-1 in August...” 26:52 – Do what App State is afraid of 29:36 – The Sun Belt East and title game picture 31:03 – The case for more JC Evans 36:02 – Sun Belt fans and “on to the American” 38:07 – Sun Belt scenarios 39:13 – Overreaction Corner (136 submissions) 47:54 – JMU Sports News tailgate plans for the Coastal game 48:52 – “It’s a national story” and JMU’s overtime history 50:17 – Outro

Music licensed through Soundstripe. License codes: LTYTDCIRPZMIXZRI, NC7LKDLIHV3OAAVB, 15V4BOX2N0NNLVJO

Got a take or a question? Email us: JMUSportsNews@gmail.com Support the show: BuyMeACoffee.com/JMUSportsNews JMUSportsNews.com | @JMUSportsNews on all socials

The Troy preview pod drops tomorrow. Subscribe so you never miss it.

#JMUFootball #JamesMadison #AppStateFootball #SunBeltFootball #GoDukes #CollegeFootball


Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

Episodes: JMU Sports News Network

PodliGet the free Podli app
↓ App