Best Buffalo Sports Babyface Turns

On this episode of Talking Buffalo Podcast, Patrick Moran and Joe From Queens dive into the greatest Buffalo sports “babyface turns” ever. Inspired by pro wrestling storytelling, the guys discuss Buffalo athletes, coaches, and personalities who went from being disliked or doubted to beloved fan favorites. From Jim Kelly’s rocky arrival in Buffalo to Josh Allen winning over Bills Mafia, the conversation blends sports nostalgia, humor, and passionate debate. The episode also features reactions to blockbuster NFL trades involving Myles Garrett and AJ Brown, plus plenty of entertaining tangents along the way.

Key Takeaways

• Jim Kelly’s transformation from rejected draft pick to Buffalo legend remains one of the greatest fan turnarounds in franchise history.
• Josh Allen’s early criticism from Bills fans quickly evolved into MVP-level admiration and citywide love.
• The guys debate whether the Los Angeles Rams’ aggressive roster-building strategy should inspire the Bills.
• Sean McDermott’s public perception shifted dramatically over the years, especially following recent Bills playoff runs.
• Fun comparisons between Buffalo sports and professional wrestling create one of the podcast’s most entertaining discussions.

Timestamps / Chapters

• 00:00 – Introduction & NFL blockbuster trade reactions
• 08:45 – Myles Garrett trade fallout and Rams discussion
• 22:30 – AJ Brown trade impact on the AFC East
• 35:10 – Greatest Buffalo sports babyface turns ever
• 58:40 – Bills media personalities, wrestling comparisons & fan reactions

Resources Mentioned

• Buffalo Bills
• Buffalo Sabres
• Jim Kelly
• Josh Allen
• Myles Garrett
• AJ Brown
• WWE Raw

Make sure to check outJoe From Queen’s Substack page for his free weekly columns.

Today’s episode is brought to you by the law offices of William Mattar. Hurt in a car, call William Mattar. 444-4444. Call William Mattar today to get the compensation you deserve.

The Talking Buffalo online merch store is now live! You can purchase t shirts, hoodies, zip ups, crewnecks and polos in a couple of different styles and colors. Visit our online page for pricing and options and while there, check out Buf on Weck for tons of cool gear!

Please be sure to subscribe to Talking Buffalo on the audio side, even if you usually watch the show via YouTube. Several of the links to follow Talking Buffalo can be found right here.

Also if you’re not yet subscribed to Talking Buffalo on YouTube, please do so and be sure to hit the LIKE button on the videos, it really helps with the algorithm!

♦♦♦♦♦

Follow Patrick Moran/Talking Buffalo Podcast 

Substack: Patrick Moran’s Substack

Twitter: @PatrickMoranTB

Blue Sky: @PatrickMoranTB.bsky.social

Instagram: @PatrickMoranTB

Facebook: Talking Buffalo Podcast 

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.