The Arise Podcast · Nov 18, 2021 · 41:46
Listen in the Podli app 🎧
Follow your favourite podcasts, listen offline and in the car with CarPlay and Android Auto, and always pick up where you left off. Free to try.
Back by popular demand, David Hayward, the NakedPastor returns to the Arise Podcast.
You can listen our first conversation with David HERE.
David is a cartoon artist who uses his art to challenge the status quo, deconstruct dogma, and offer hope for those who struggle and suffer under it. After 30 years in the church, he left the ministry to pursue his passion for art. He holds a Masters in Theological Studies. He is also a writer with several books, and is based out of New Brunswick, Canada.
We wanted to circle back with David to explore and expand the idea of Spiritual Abuse which often appears in his art. Maggie asked him to start us off with a working definition.
David said he knows religious abuse or spiritual abuse intimately and from both sides: he has been on the receiving end, that is he has been personally harmed as well as he has participated in the structures that have inflicted spiritual abuse.
As for a working definition, David said Wikipedia’s definition is a good place to start: “Religious abuse is abuse administered under the guise of religion, including harassment or humiliation, which may result in psychological trauma. Religious abuse may also include misuse of religion for selfish, secular, or ideological ends such as the abuse of a clerical position.” There are so many forms of abuse (emotional, physical, sexual, etc.) but it can be simply said that abuse is when someone’s self is being violated in some way. Spiritual abuse is then when anything that falls under the spirituality / religious realm is used as a weapon to violate another person’s freedom, dignity or their physical or emotional self.
Some people, he says, have a hard time accepting that Christianity, Faith, the Bible or religion can be used as a weapon. “Right of the bat, their defenses go up. ‘Impossible! Because ‘Christianity is a good thing.’” Religion, like any good thing, can be turned around and used to harm another person or people group.
Abuse of power, like the clerical position and spiritual leaders, can be used to harm others. This is an overt and severe expression of spiritual abuse like you see in the examples from the cases of clergy with their membership, especially in the Roman Catholic Church with sexual abuse of boys by priests. There are also more subtle or as David says “mild” forms of spiritual abuse that just comes off as “uncomfortable” feeling, like “something doesn’t sit right” as would be the case in someone feeling the pressure to give of financial resources or time and energy to the church.
Danielle says David has named that spiritual abuse is an abuse of someone’s identity, who God created them to be, and therefore it encompasses a range of things that can violated making it all the more devious.
David says that people would categorize sexual assault, sexual abuse, rape or sexual harassment under the category of sexuality but he believes there’s something even more foundational than that and it is human dignity, their self-space, their pride and freedom is being violated. When you consider the sexual abuse of the Roman Catholic Church, it is being done under the guise that there is a spiritual union happening. This adds another layer to the abuse – it is both sexual and spiritual violations. There’s a clear abuse of power when a pastor has an affair with one of its members—there can’t be consent with the power dynamic. This is the same as a professor with a student. It’s not just rare cases, this is happening all over the place.
Maggie says she thinks of the word rampant—it’s happening all over and it’s happening all the time. One of the things that is hard to identifying is abuse when it’s subtle. She says it’s easier to identify spiritual abuse in cases like the priest sexually abusing boys-–it’s a clear misuse of power. But it’s harder to identify cases of subtle spiritual abuse where it’s more like a warping of scripture or misuse of theology. Something feels off and you may feel uncomfortable but you also want to trust the pastor or spiritual leader. “It doesn’t seem wrong; they’re using the Bible.” “They’re looking out for me.” We have all kinds of ways to rationalize away the possibility of spiritual abuse, to give the “leadership” the benefit of the doubt, when in fact they are weaponizing scripture to instill fear and self-doubt so you feel like you can no longer trust yourself.
David says that is happening just about everywhere. He gives two examples, one in which he inflicted and one in which he was the recipient of:
When he was fresh out of seminary, 25 years old, preaching “with great zeal” to the three Presbyterian churches in his charge, he taught on the importance of reading the Bible and knowing the Bible. Afterwards he felt bad and even apologized the following Sunday for being so “pushy” and making people feel guilty about not reading the Bible. The response he got was, “No, no, no! We loved it! We want you to do more of it.” They liked the “hell, fire and brimstone that makes them feel bad.” It was a weird dynamic—people expect to be preached at, to be pressured into good things and to be made to feel guilty and shamed for falling short. David realized that he didn’t want to brow-beat people because he knew from his own life how effective that was: Zero.
Much later in life, after he had left the ministry, he was invited to attend a “very liberal” church with a friend. God wasn’t mentioned, everyone one sharing the service, but when the pastor got up to preach, he could feel himself physically leaning back to get away from the pastor. The pastor was teaching against the dichotomy of spiritual but not religious and shaming them for not being more religious. He decided he would never go